Your first month for R1 Then your plan price. Cancel any time.
Start free
Case law by topic

Judgments on appeal

1003 judgments on file that touch appeal, newest first, each with the court's own file.

Handed downJudgmentCourt
23 Dec 2025 Wares v Additional Magistrate, Simonstown and Others[2025] ZACC 29 · Extradition Act 67 of 1962 — constitutionality of section 10(1) —section is unconstitutional to the extent that it does not make provision f... Constitutional Court
19 Dec 2025 Deon Smith and Others v Sasfin Bank and Another[2025] ZASCA 198 · Section 17(2)(f) of the Superior Courts Act of 2013 – reconsideration application – Uniform Rules of Court – refusal of application for resc... Supreme Court of Appeal
19 Dec 2025 Cele v The State[2025] ZASCA 199 · Criminal Procedure – sentence – murder – effective sentence of years imprisonment – whether shockingly inappropriate. Section 274 of the Cri... Supreme Court of Appeal
19 Dec 2025 The Road Accident Fund & Others v Mautla and Others[2025] ZASCA 200 · Superior Courts Act of 2013 – section 17(2)(f) – application for reconsideration of refusal of leave to appeal – section 16(1)(b) – test for... Supreme Court of Appeal
18 Dec 2025 Jurnic Properties CC and Another v Victor Khanye Local Municipality and Others[2025] ZASCA 196 · Constitutional Law – review in terms of s 6(2) of the Promotion of Administrative Justice Act of 2000 – requirements for own-interest standi... Supreme Court of Appeal
18 Dec 2025 The Central Authority for the Republic of South Africa v MV and Another[2025] ZASCA 197 · The 1980 Hague Convention on the Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction – application for the return of a minor child to Switzerland... Supreme Court of Appeal
17 Dec 2025 Badenhorst N O v Manyatta Properties Close Corporation and Others[2025] ZASCA 194 Supreme Court of Appeal
17 Dec 2025 Collins Letsoalo and Another v Mothusi Lukhele[2025] ZASCA 195 · Civil procedure – application for reconsideration of refusal of leave to appeal – Section 17(2)(f) of the Superior Courts Act of 2013 – moot... Supreme Court of Appeal
15 Dec 2025 North West Provincial Department of Agriculture, Conservation, Environmental and Rural Development and Another v Bosigo Investment and Trading CC and Another[2025] ZASCA 191 · Damages – claim for loss of profit arising from breach of contract – plaintiff bears onus to identify and prove saved expenses to be deducte... Supreme Court of Appeal
15 Dec 2025 Malakite Body Corporate and Another v City of Johannesburg Metropolitan Municipality and Another[2025] ZASCA 192 · Municipal Law – Standardisation of Electricity By-Law 1999 – appropriate electricity tariff classification – meaning of and application of s... Supreme Court of Appeal
15 Dec 2025 Christensen N O and Another v De Magalhaes[2025] ZASCA 193 · Law of Insolvency – application for special leave to appeal in terms of the Superior Courts Act of 2013 – referred for oral argument – speci... Supreme Court of Appeal
11 Dec 2025 Moagi v The State[2025] ZASCA 188 · Sentence – failure to pronounce on common purpose where conviction is in terms of s 51(1) of the Criminal Law Amendment Act 105 of 1997 – fa... Supreme Court of Appeal
4 Dec 2025 NAD Property Income Fund (Pty) Ltd v Bushbuckridge Local Municipality and Another[2025] ZASCA 184 · Arbitration – Arbitration Act of 1965 (Arbitration Act) – whether an arbitrator, in arbitration proceedings, is empowered to declare invalid... Supreme Court of Appeal
4 Dec 2025 Clanwilliam and Others[2025] ZASCA 185 · Inquest Proceedings – Inquests Act of 1959 – whether the magistrate misdirected himself by not holding a public inquest and hearing oral evi... Supreme Court of Appeal
1 Dec 2025 Lekeka v The State[2025] ZASCA 182 · Criminal Law – s 17(2)(f) of Superior Courts Act of 2013 – application for reconsideration of a decision refusing special leave to appeal –... Supreme Court of Appeal
1 Dec 2025 Ntayiya v South African Revenue Service[2025] ZASCA 183 · Tax law – Income Tax Act of 1962 – Tax Administration Act of 2011 – assessments of taxpayer – whether submission of nil returns by taxpayer... Supreme Court of Appeal
28 Nov 2025 Johannes Wessel Greeff v Body Corporate of Merriman Court and Others[2025] ZASCA 176 · Law of Property – requirements for the extension of a sectional unit prescribed in Sectional Titles Act of 1986 and Sectional Titles Schemes... Supreme Court of Appeal
28 Nov 2025 Skhumbuzo Zulu v Vikizitha R Mlotshwa and Others[2025] ZASCA 177 · Appeal – notice of appeal and the record of appeal lodged late – applications for condonation in respect of lateness – application for the r... Supreme Court of Appeal
28 Nov 2025 Samuel Alfred Schoonhoven N O and Others v Pieter Cornelius Antonius Schoonhoven and Others[2025] ZASCA 178 · Trusts – discretionary trust – designation of capital beneficiaries – testamentary reservation – founder’s right to designate – scope of the... Supreme Court of Appeal
28 Nov 2025 Mafoko Security Patrols (Pty) Ltd and Others v Mjayeli Security (Pty) Ltd and Others[2025] ZASCA 179 · Tender – invalidity – remedy – s 172(1)(a) and (b) of the Constitution – just and equitable remedy – unlawful award – tenderer continues to... Supreme Court of Appeal
28 Nov 2025 Tekoa Consulting Engineers (Pty) Ltd v Alfred Nzo District Municipality and Others[2025] ZASCA 180 · Municipal law – tender – mootness – no practical effect – discrete legal issue of public importance – Review – standing – lateness – vaguene... Supreme Court of Appeal
21 Nov 2025 Showroom Centre (Pty) Ltd and Others v Ronald Kagan[2025] ZASCA 175 · Civil procedure – leave to appeal – reconsideration in terms of s 17(2)(f) of the Superior Courts Act of 2013 of refusal of leave to appeal... Supreme Court of Appeal
14 Nov 2025 Naledi Local Municipality and Others v Appolus and Others[2025] ZASCA 171 · Local Government: Municipal Systems Act of 2000 – interpretation of s 54A – review of the appointment of a Municipal Manager – whether groun... Supreme Court of Appeal
14 Nov 2025 AIG South Africa Limited and Others v Azrapart (Pty) Ltd and Another[2025] ZASCA 172 · Insurance law – antecedent insurance agreements – whether the insurance contract falls to be rectified – whether antecedent agreements were... Supreme Court of Appeal
13 Nov 2025 South Africa Riding for the Disabled Association v Regional Land Claims Commission, Western Cape and Others[2025] ZACC 25 · Land — land reform — restitution — claim — right to intervene of lawful occupier — may intervene only for purpose of determining compensatio... Constitutional Court
12 Nov 2025 Moloto v The State[2025] ZASCA 169 · Sentence – the existence of substantial and compelling circumstances warranting deviation from prescribed minimum sentences – brutality of o... Supreme Court of Appeal
12 Nov 2025 Groundswell Developments Africa (Pty) Ltd and Others v Brown[2025] ZASCA 170 · Section 17(2)(f) of the Superior Courts Act of 2013 – validity of the agreement of sale – validity of the builder’s lien relied upon misrepr... Supreme Court of Appeal
7 Nov 2025 South African Legal Practice Council v Oosthuizen[2025] ZASCA 168 · Legal Practice – Attorney – Professional Misconduct – Application for striking from roll – Legal Practice Act of 2014 – s 40(8) provides tha... Supreme Court of Appeal
5 Nov 2025 Zolani Godloza and Another v The State[2025] ZACC 24 · Jurisdiction — constitutional matter — potential limitation of the right not to be deprived of freedom arbitrarily and without just cause Ju... Constitutional Court
4 Nov 2025 Waterberg Boulevard (Pty) Ltd v Smulhoekie Tuisnywerheid (Pty) Ltd and Another[2025] ZASCA 167 · Civil Law – Magistrates’ Courts Act of 1944 – Whether a claim for arrear rental is a claim for specific performance in terms of s 46 – monet... Supreme Court of Appeal
31 Oct 2025 King Sabata Dalindyebo Local Municipality & Others v Hintsa and Others[2025] ZASCA 165 · Interpretation of the resolution – whether the resolution taken by the municipality’s council applied to the respondents - whether the respo... Supreme Court of Appeal
31 Oct 2025 Sterea Digital CC and Another v The City of Cape Town and Others[2025] ZASCA 166 · Municipal law – property – rezoning application. Administrative Law – Promotion of Administrative Justice Act of 2000, ss 6(2)(e)(iii) and 6... Supreme Court of Appeal
28 Oct 2025 Logik Group Africa (Pty) Ltd t/a Fire Logik v Fire Logic (Pty) Ltd[2025] ZASCA 164 · Delict– Passing-off proceedings onus of proving reputation for passing- off application discharged – whether the respondent established the... Supreme Court of Appeal
27 Oct 2025 Els v Venter and Another[2025] ZASCA 163 · Statutory interpretation – Consumer Protection Act of 2008 – meaning and effect of ‘transaction’, ‘service’ and ‘rental’ – whether residenti... Supreme Court of Appeal
24 Oct 2025 National Council of and for Persons with Disabilities v Independent Communications Authority of SA[2025] ZASCA 161 · Administrative law – unreasonable delay in instituting review proceedings – explanation not reasonable – no basis to interfere with discreti... Supreme Court of Appeal
23 Oct 2025 Nordien and Another v Kidrogen RF (Pty) Ltd and Another[2025] ZASCA 159 · Property law – eviction – lease agreement signed by directors of the company which owned the property without indicating that they acted on... Supreme Court of Appeal
23 Oct 2025 Thembakazi Ntangazana v Member of Executive Council for The Department of Education, Eastern Cape[2025] ZASCA 160 · Lapsed reconsideration application in terms of s 17(2)(f) of the Superior Courts Act of 2013 – inadequate delay explanation trumped by good... Supreme Court of Appeal
21 Oct 2025 Municipal Employees Pension Fund v City of Johannesburg Metropolitan Municipality and Others[2025] ZACC 23 · [Locus standi] — [substitution of litigant] — [standing in review proceedings] — [legal effect of an order of substitution after litis conte... Constitutional Court
21 Oct 2025 Portapa (Pty) Limited t/a Supabets and Others v Casino Association of South Africa and Another, andThe Gauteng Gambling Board v Casino Association of South Africa v Portaba (Pty) Ltd t/a Supabets and Others (182/2024 & 215/2024)[2025] ZASCA 158 · Gambling Laws: Interpretation of ‘sporting event’ in s of the Gauteng Gambling Act of 1995 – limiting fixed-odds bets with bookmakers to ‘sp... Supreme Court of Appeal
20 Oct 2025 The City of Johannesburg Metropolitan Municipality and Another v Seale and Another[2025] ZASCA 156 · Application of s 17(2)(f) of the Superior Courts Act of 2013 – – existence of two orders issued by this Court on application for leave to ap... Supreme Court of Appeal
20 Oct 2025 Lopes and Another v Executive Mayor of the Knysna Local Municipality & Others[2025] ZASCA 157 · Mootness – appeal having no practical effect – whether discrete legal point arises – general principles restated. Supreme Court of Appeal
17 Oct 2025 Walker and Another v Schabort Potgieter Attorneys Inc and Others (320/2024 and 368/ 2024)[2025] ZASCA 154 · Claim of a company in liquidation for assets recovered by an attorney – attorney’s duty to account and debatement of accounts-whether s 32(1... Supreme Court of Appeal
17 Oct 2025 Parch Properties 72 (Pty) Ltd v Summervale Lifestyle Estate Owner’s Association and Others[2025] ZASCA 155 · Community Schemes Ombud Act of 2011 – jurisdiction of the high court not ousted – whether refusal to amend the constitution of a Community S... Supreme Court of Appeal
16 Oct 2025 NT Makhubele Enterprises CC & Others v Business Partners Limited[2025] ZASCA 151 · Costs – review of taxation – party who fails to attend taxation cannot invoke review procedure under 17(3) of the Rules Regulating the Condu... Supreme Court of Appeal
16 Oct 2025 Itokolle-Clinix Private Hospital (Pty) Ltd v MNT obo DORM[2025] ZASCA 153 · Delict – medical negligence – injury to foetal brain – child born suffering from cerebral palsy – admitted negligence by nursing staff in mo... Supreme Court of Appeal
14 Oct 2025 Christoffel Jacobus Petrus Wolmarans N O and Others v The Standard Bank of South Africa Limited[2025] ZASCA 150 · National Credit Act of 2005 (the Act) – suretyship granted in respect of credit agreement to which Act applies – settlement agreements concl... Supreme Court of Appeal
9 Oct 2025 The IPA Foundation (NPC) v South African Pharmacy Council[2025] ZASCA 148 · Pharmacy Act of 1974 – Pharmacy Council’s power to expand the scope of practice of pharmacists to provide pharmacist-initiated management of... Supreme Court of Appeal
8 Oct 2025 Pepkor Holdings Ltd, Shoprite Furniture Ltd and Lewis Stores LimitedCAC 271/CAC/Jul25 · Competition law – Appeal against decision of the Competition Tribunal granting leave to respondent to intervene in merger proceedings under... Competition Appeal Court
7 Oct 2025 Motsima and Another v Kopa and Others[2025] ZASCA 144 · Application for condonation – failure to prosecute appeal – reinstatement of lapsed appeal – inordinate delay – long periods of delay unexpl... Supreme Court of Appeal
7 Oct 2025 Khamusi Shonisani Mudau-Mamode v Vhuhwaho Denge[2025] ZASCA 145 · Civil procedure – Magistrates’ Court Rules – rule 55(1)(k) – whether the regional court and the full bench were correct in dismissing the ap... Supreme Court of Appeal

A judgment is listed here when the court's own summary or its title uses the term; it is a finding aid, not a headnote. All topics.